“Which AI image engine should I use for product photos?”

Which AI image engine should you use for product photos?

Short answer

Pick the engine by testing, not by reputation. Run the same three products through two engines and check color, shape, text and scale against the real item. Sellamander, coming soon, starts with your ChatGPT plan, no cost per image, then API keys for OpenAI, Google Gemini, OpenRouter or Replicate. Images bill to the engine you pick.

1Pick threeproducts2Use the samelook3Run two engines4Check fourthings5Keep the betterengine

Steps

  1. 1

    Pick three products

    Choose one plain, one shiny and one with text on the label.

  2. 2

    Use the same look

    Keep the look and the source photo the same for each engine.

  3. 3

    Run two engines

    Make one photo per product on each engine.

  4. 4

    Check four things

    Compare color, shape, text and scale with the real item.

  5. 5

    Keep the better engine

    Use it for the catalog. You can switch later in Settings, Content.

The image engine options

Sellamander lists five image engines. Each one bills to a different place, and that is the main difference you can plan around.

Those are your ChatGPT plan, with no cost per image, and your own API key for OpenAI, Google Gemini, OpenRouter or Replicate.

What each engine bills to

Your ChatGPT plan is used through Codex, so images count against that plan, with no cost per image.

OpenAI (GPT Image 2.5), Google Gemini (Nano Banana 2, Pro or Lite), OpenRouter (Nano Banana or Seedream 4.5) and Replicate each use your own API key. Images bill to that account. Read each provider's own pricing page before you run a whole catalog.

How to test two engines

Choose three products: one plain, one shiny and one with text on the label. Make one photo of each with each engine, using the same look and the same source photo.

Open the real product photo next to each result. Check color, shape, text and scale. Reject any image that changes the product. Count how many of the six photos you would be happy to publish.

Five or six photos are enough to see the difference. They also show how much of your plan or account a full catalog would use. For the full check see the AI product photo accuracy checklist.

Why this page does not rank the engines

Quality claims about image models come mostly from the companies that make them. Results also change by product, so one engine can do well on mugs and badly on labels. A test on your own products is the only comparison that tells you something.

Every engine sits behind the same step in Sellamander. You approve or reject each new photo, so a weak result never reaches a post or your store.

The caption engine is separate

Captions use their own engine, chosen in Settings, Content. Options are Anthropic Claude, OpenAI, Google Gemini, OpenRouter, xAI Grok and Moonshot Kimi. You can use one provider for images and another for captions.

The Simple caption style needs no AI at all. See AI captions for product posts.

Switching later

The engine is a setting, not a commitment. Your products, looks and approved photos stay in Sellamander when you change it. New photos use the new engine.

Sellamander is coming soon. The download page is a waitlist with an email when it opens.

Questions

Can I use my ChatGPT subscription for product photos?

Yes. Sellamander can use your ChatGPT plan as the image engine, with no cost per image.

What is the difference between a ChatGPT subscription and an API key?

A subscription is the plan you pay for ChatGPT. An API key bills per use to a developer account. In Sellamander, the subscription option uses your ChatGPT plan, and the OpenAI option uses an API key.

Which AI is best for product photos?

It depends on your products. Test two engines on the same three products and judge each result against the real item.

Is Nano Banana good for product photos?

Sellamander offers Nano Banana 2, Pro or Lite through Google Gemini with your API key, and Nano Banana through OpenRouter. Test it on your own products and approve only the photos that match the item.

What does a redo cost?

On your ChatGPT plan there is no cost per image. On your own API key, a redo bills to that account like any other image.

Do I need a separate key for captions?

Captions use their own engine in Settings, Content. If you pick a provider you already use for images, you can use the same account.

Can I switch engines later?

Yes. Change the image engine in Settings, Content. New photos use the new engine.

How many free images do I get?

Sellamander does not sell images. Your ChatGPT plan has no cost per image, and an API key bills to that account.

Sources

  1. Sellamander (checked 2026-10-18)

Related

Get Sellamander updates

Free for 14 days. No card. One trial per Mac.